I've been fascinated by Slate.com music critic Jody Rosen's story, "Dude, You Stole My Article." Rosen discovered that a "Mark Williams," a writer for a small alt-weekly in Texas (its website is now down), the Montgomery County Bulletin, had plagiarized a Jimmy Buffett feature that Rosen had written. Intrigued/pissed off, Rosen decided to dig farther:
Since 2005, the
Bulletin has published dozens of stories under
Williams' byline that appear to be copied, whole or in part, from other
periodicals. Compare the
Bulletin's Nov. 4, 2005,
Franz Ferdinand piece and this
NME review, published five weeks prior; the
Bulletin's Steely Dan piece (July 14, 2006) and this article from the Web site
All About Jazz (July 4, 2006); the
Bulletin's
Black Rebel Motorcycle Club featureBoston Globe piece (May 25, 2007); the
Bulletin's
McKay Brothers articleDallas Observer item (Oct. 19, 2006); and the
Bulletin's "
God and Country: More Popular Artists Are Now Singing a Spiritual Tune" (Sept. 20, 2007) and the
Billie Joe Shaver concert review by
Washington Post pop critic J. Freedom du Lac (Sept. 13, 2007). The
Eagles piece published in the
Bulletin on Dec. 13, 2007 is a nearly word-for-word recapitulation of
David Fricke's Rolling Stone review (Nov. 1, 2007). Mark Williams sought inspiration from
USA Today for his features on Paul Simon (
USA Today version;
Bulletin version) and Tom Petty (
USA Today version;
Bulletin version). The Evanston, Ill.-based blog
Pop Matters is the apparent source of articles on Dwight Yoakam (
Pop Matters version;
Bulletin version) and Matthew Sweet and Susanna Hoffs (
Pop Matters version;
Bulletin version). And then there's "
Crazy About 'Crazy'
" (March 2, 2007), Williams' deconstruction of the monster 2006 pop hit
by Gnarls Barkley—an article that bears a striking resemblance to "
Crazy for 'Crazy'," published six months earlier in
Slate.
Rosen spoke to the paper's editor, Mike Ladyman, but then Ladyman rabbited and went to ground. After Slate ran Rosen's feature, though, the Bulletin abruptly folded and Ladyman and WIlliams (or, as it appears, Ladyman/Williams) went on a pity-party attack, blaming Rosen for taking their/his mendacity public. From the Houston Press interview with Ladyman:
"It is a low-budget publication. Or was. It’s no longer a publication. I’m quitting. After this Slate article and this is the future of journalism in New York City [sic]. I don’t want any part of it.”
But it was "Williams"' open letter to Jody Rosen that iced this cake. It reads, in part:
It must have taken years of seasoned investigative know-how to push me
off my lofty perch. It takes a dogged, intrepid journalist to expose
the alleged wrongdoings of a 44-year-old college dropout who drifted
from one lousy media job to another for 20 years; it takes courage to
debase someone with a mouthful of cut-rate dentures who, up until 2007,
lived in his parents’ home for seven years due to near-fatal bouts of
clinical depression; it takes a journalist of a certain caliber to
torpedo a pathetic hack who has barely squeezed out a living for nearly
a decade at seven cents a word....
It is easy to make fun of our little rag, Mr. Rosen -- to call
attention to the gaffes and human foibles of a couple of faceless rubes
a half a nation away; but, despite your grievances with our
publication, I feel that we have done some good in our corner of the
world. Through our output of articles over the years, we kept a hateful
rogue element of the local Republican Party from taking control of our
county library system and ripping the Constitution to shreds; we have
reported unblinkingly on the troubled plight of illegal aliens living
in our area; we have stood face-to-face with members of the Ku Klux
Klan to question their ideological inconsistencies; and we touched the
heart of a killer who turned himself in after reading an article in our
publication on his victim, who, for years, struggled with alcoholism
and the estrangement it caused with his family. In short, we have
called attention to a great number of injustices in our crappy little
town, both great and small.
So there it is, Mr. Rosen -- congratulations on breaking an already
fragile soul. In the end, I’m not sure what the point of all of this
truly is, other than some sort of small dully colored feather in your
journalistic cap. We bow to you, Mr. Rosen -- to your talent, to your
humanity, to all that is you.
Hey, Jody Rosen: nice feather, man.