Just under the wire comes one of the best pieces of investigative-feature journalism I've read all year: Nancy Rommelmann's dissection in Willamette Week of the strange death of a Vancouver, Wa. mother and her chronically ill 14-year-old daughter.
This case got huge media attention in Portland when it happened -- the Oregonian reported that detectives suspected murder-suicide; the Tribune elided the issue with a story headlined "Mom, daughter lose lives," and all the local TV stations ran pieces on the tragedy. Rommelmann smelled fish, and the results of her investigation should win her some national awards:
The Oregonian story about the murder-suicide was headlined
“Vancouver mom spent her life trying to get best for daughter” and
included a photo of Rebecca singing with Yarrow [Peter Yarrow, of Peter, Paul, and Mary, who held a fundraiser for the family right before the deaths], noting that the girl
“had cerebral palsy and dyslexia.” The story mentioned how Laurie, a
single mother, “couldn’t hold a job given the time needed to care for
Rebecca” and due to her own pain from fibromyalgia.
In the coming weeks, there would be memorials. At Clark
County Chabad, Rabbi Shmulik Greenberg spoke of Rebecca’s piety, her
enthusiasm. After services, attendees shook their heads. Laurie had
fought tenaciously, they said, for the child born prematurely and
burdened with a nearly unfathomable number of illnesses and
disabilities. This little girl and her mother had survived so much, and
for this to happen, none of it made any sense.
What no one knew was that Rebecca’s mom had made much of it up.
This case of apparent Munchausen's syndrome by proxy is absolutely chilling, and it says as much about the gullible local media climate as it does the family in this case. Why Nancy Rommelmann is a freelancer and not a staff investigative reporter in Portland is, in one sense, a complete mystery -- and, in a larger sense, not a mystery at all.